Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Sean - Reflection #4

Today’s meeting with my one-on-one student was a little different. Until now she has worked a job at the Dallas Ft. Worth Airport cleaning toilets. This time after coming in we exchanged greetings and during the course of the conversation it became apparent that she had lost her job. Upon pressing her, it turns out that she was fired because she could not read.

This was shocking for me. As a cleaning lady, I didn’t think that there would be a huge need for reading ability. Her co-worker had taught her how to recognize different cleaning materials by sight, and she had learned the words used on the cleaning checklists. Even though she had done this, she was still released from her job.

Events like this really bring the lives of immigrants, especially refugees, into focus. Refugees are admitted into the United States as a means of escape from war, poverty, and death. However the life that awaits them here is tough. They are faced with a society markedly different from their own, with a different language to learn in a short amount of time. My student’s husband is still in Africa, and she supports three children here.

This event made me look at my class another way. Until now, I had been content to do what she wanted to learn. She was interested in just reading the book, and felt that it was enough. I realized that constant needs analyses are integral to a class, especially in a one-on-one setting. She is learning to read, and for an adult who has never been able to read, I feel that her level of achievement is high. However, as head of household and responsible for three children, I feel she must try harder. It’s impossible to rely on the translation efforts of her friends and children forever, especially if she wants to get a better job, and more importantly, keep it.

So I will continue to re-evaluate my class. I will slowly start to integrate more grammar into our sessions, and focus on it until she learns. It may not necessarily be her preferred method of study, but without more grammar I feel her reading skill will not improve to a degree that gives her an advantage in the job market.

1 comment:

  1. I'm so sorry to hear that your student lost her job! I think the idea of incorporating more into her lessons is good, in that you are assessing her needs and, knowing her situation, you see a need that she does not even see yet. This is often the case with teachers - we do want to provide our students with what they want, but we can see well beyond their current position, so we may identify different needs than they do.

    If you want to incorporate more grammar but she wants to read more, why not do both together? Use her reading text to point out different grammatical structures and what they mean. If you want some examples, let me know - we used an approach much like this in the language program i taught in at UCSD, and had great success with at least some students.

    ReplyDelete