My class is a beginner class, but within that one class there are a variety of levels. This is a problem that many volunteer teachers have to deal with, and one that has no easy solution. I want to look at level variance within a class and ways to get around it.
At Arlington Reads, the students are given a leveling test to determine where they should be placed. As the main focus of AR is on literacy, the test results can sometimes be misleading and lead to skewed leveling results. Case in point is the dominant student in my class. When speaking to him, it is obvious from his grammatical constructions and his choice of vocabulary that his level is above the other students. However, his shaky and nearly illegible handwriting and inability to answer many of the questions correctly on the test put him in a lower level.
Other students are granted access to a class based on availability. My lowest level student is low beginner, and her conversation is limited to short sentences and disconnected vocabulary. When she joined my class, she was concurrently taking a class using the level 1 textbook (my class uses level 2). This made my job difficult, as my textbook was obviously building upon something that she hadn’t covered yet. However, she had a friend in the class who was willing to support her and help her in their native language, so I allowed it.
Because of its nature as an adult ESL class students rated beginner or not come in with a widely varying range of experience. Some students have a great grasp of grammar while others have a large vocabulary. When teaching some material is bound to be old review and some might be too hard. It is up to the teacher to help give the higher students an extra challenge while helping low level students catch up to their classmates. I have been trying to do this as much as possible in the class, but it is not an easy undertaking. It is balance that teachers must strive to reach.
In a situation like this, where both teachers and students are volunteers, would you do things differently? In other words, would you disallow a lower-level student to attend if you were the one in charge? Would you disallow a higher-level student from attending? Why or why not?
ReplyDelete