My second class observation was in a Level 2 Listening & Speaking class in ELI taught by Terry Ceballos in Business Building in UT Arlington. There were about 15 students in the class. There were many Korean and Vietnamese students in her class. She started the class with reviewing what they had learned in previous classes. The students’ reaction was very good, too.
There were various kinds of group activities: for example, they had a small group discussion about the symptoms they had at the moment and a pair activity of a doctor-patient role play. She used explicit correction as well as recast as her correcting strategy while listening to her students. I love her informal monitoring for striking a balance between talkative students and reserved ones. She kept on asking questions to shy students in a very casual manner so that they could also answer back casually. For reserved students, very oftentimes, it is hard even to open their mouth to say anything. In this respect, she was doing a very good job to make the students talk in class.
I felt a little bit problematic in the group activities. It was not because dominant students were occupying most of the time but because I could feel the level difference among students. I thought it was due to the placement test. There was an Asian guy whose speaking proficiency is way better than others. I thought he should have been in a Level 4 or 5 in Listening & Speaking. He knew a lot of difficult vocabularies in the given topics and seemed to be bored in the class. I still do not know why the guy was in the class. I highly suspect that he was very nervous or sick while taking the placement test.
After the class, I had a conversation with Terry about the textbook she was using for the class. There were some problems in using the textbook in the class. First of all, the chapters of the textbook talk about a very specific instance related to the topic. For example, the chapter she was dealing with on that day was about illness; however, the textbook only talks about diabetes which is a kind of illness. Likewise, the textbook only talks about hurricanes in a chapter in which the general topic is disasters. Secondly, we talked about vocabulary items in each chapter. The items were too limited to cover full prescription of each illness. As a whole, Terry and I had similar feelings about the textbook. At the same time, it reminds me of what Cindy told me: that is, sometimes, you are better than textbook authors.
I'm glad you got to observe a good monitor! I also like that you are connecting thoughts and ideas and pulling together an overall picture - the textbook thing can be problematic, but realizing it going in is the first step toward being prepared to supplement that lesson with additional relevant materials/topics.
ReplyDelete